Previous: Space Travel | Topic List
 

PHYS 206 --- Topic 20

SETI: Are other intelligent beings out there?

 




 

Pictures
 
 


20.1. Life
 

No comprehensive, universal definitions !
  • Fire?
  • Viruses?
  • Prions?
  • If ET life were discovered,

    Philosophical / religious implications

    Technological implications

      


    20.2. Life in the Solar System?
     

    Earth: 3.5 billion years ago.
    Then, Earth, Venus & Mars were similar
    Possible ancient life on Mars
     
    Viking Life Detection Experiments
    Best current candidate: Europa
    (Liquid water)
    Titan
    (organic compounds)
    Elsewhere? Dim....But
    Carl Sagan in Cosmos and Clarke in 2010 : in atmospheres of Gas Giants ?

      


    20.3. Other planetary systems?
     

    Life does not need a planet to exist (Space Habitats)

    Does it need a planet to arise?

     
    Many extrasolar planets found!
    Giants.
    Planets should be common (?)
    But stable?
    Another possibility: Trojan orbits orbits binary stars...

      


    20.4. Intelligent life in the galaxy?

    The Drake Equation:

    N = R . fp . np . fl . fi . fc . L

    R: rate of star formation (~10)
    fp: fraction of stars with planets (opt ~1)
    np: number of habitable planets per planetary system (1/10)
    fl: probability of development of life (opt ~1)
    fi: probability of developing of intelligence once life started (opt ~1)
    fc: probability of intelligent beings being communicate (~1)
    L: Average Lifetime of a technological civilization

    ⇒ N ~ L

    If  L ~ 100, N ~ 100 (even 1 ?)

    If L ~ millions, then there are millions of civilizations!

    Drake Eqn does not give an answer, it provides a formalism.

    Kardashev Classification:
  • Type 1: Can harness all energy resources of a planet

  •  
  • Type 2: Can harness all resorces of a star system

  •  
  • Type 3: Can harness all resources of a galaxy
  • too naive?
    Dyson: A Kardashev Type II civilization

    An intermadiate case: Ringworld, described by Larry Niven

     
    Galactic Zoo hypotesis

     

      


    20.5. Pro
     

    Discovery of Planetary Systems (fp: 0 ?  → → 1)

    Possibility of ancient life on Mars

    Miller - Urey experiment

    Electric discharges in a "primitive" atmosphere

    → Organic compounds, including amino acids.

    No proof needed (Some people think)

      


    20.6. Con
     

    The Fermi Question:
    "Where are they?"

    - They should be millions of years ahead

     
    - With Von Neumann machines, galaxy could be colonized in about a million years
    (check the Optional Further Reading)
    - So, why haven't they done it?
    Corollary: there is no advanced intelligence hostile to life.

    Suggestion: Effects should be detectable

    e.g. a Dyson Sphere : infrared

     

      


    20.7. Search
     

    No need? UFO's ?
    - Not one authenticated case.

    - Not fantastic enough

    - They should not be so amateurish.

    SETI - Radio
    - Maybe the only possible form...
    Signs of activity
    - Dyson Spheres

    - Spaceship exhausts?

    No success...

      


    References:

    Explorations: Essay 3: Life in the Universe


    Suggested reading: Optional further reading: From WWW:
    Previous: Space Travel | Topic List